Spend less at home, one month at a time

Tips & inspiration Straight to the point
Practical ideas What actually works
New articles Every week
Newsletter Our best ideas by email Subscribe

Thrift shopping at Goodwill: what to buy used and what to skip

Leah Carter Avatar

·

3 min read 5.0 (61 ratings)

Thrift stores can trim a household budget quickly, but only if you shop with a plan. Buying a $4 item you do not need is no better than buying a $40 one, and a few categories of secondhand goods carry real safety questions. The nonprofit Goodwill runs stores across the country, and the same rules apply at most thrift shops, church sales, and community swaps.

Good candidates for buying used

Items that are sturdy, simple, and hard to damage tend to be the best deals. Cast iron pans, glass baking dishes, solid wood furniture, hardcover books, and wool or denim clothing often outlast their newer equivalents. Kids’ clothing is another strong category, because children outgrow things long before they wear them out. Look for tight seams, intact zippers, and fabric that has not pilled or faded unevenly.

Think of secondhand shopping as a way to pay less for quality. A well-made jacket for $12 beats a flimsy new one for $30, but a flimsy used one for $12 is still a waste.

Items to buy new, or inspect very carefully

Safety standards for children’s products change over time, and some used items may have been made before newer rules took effect. The Consumer Product Safety Commission publishes recalls and safety guidance, and it is smart to search it before you buy a crib, car seat, high chair, or any secondhand product made for babies. When in doubt, skip it. Helmets, mattresses, and anything with a damaged cord also belong on the cautious list, since a hidden defect is hard to spot in a store aisle.

Here is a quick comparison to carry in your head or on your phone.

Item Buy used or new What to check Where to look
Cast iron skillet Used No cracks or deep rust pits; flat bottom Housewares aisle
Glass baking dish Used No chips, cracks, or cloudy spots Housewares aisle
Children’s clothing Used Stains, missing buttons, loose seams Kids’ racks
Wooden furniture Used Sturdy joints, no wobble, no mildew smell Furniture section
Hardcover books Used Intact binding, no water damage Book shelves
Crib or car seat New Recall notices and current safety rules Skip the thrift aisle
Bike helmet New A damaged helmet may not protect you Skip the thrift aisle
Mattress New Hygiene and hidden wear Skip the thrift aisle
Small electronics Used, with caution Frayed cords, burn marks, working plug Electronics shelf

Before you pay: a short checklist

  1. Test what you can. Plug in lamps, zip zippers, open drawers, and sniff for smoke or mildew.
  2. Compare the price with new. If a used blender costs 80% of a new one, the new one with a warranty is the better deal.
  3. Know the return policy. Many thrift stores offer little or none, so decide with that in mind.
  4. Wash and disinfect. Launder clothing and wash hard goods before using them at home.

Shop with a list and a cap

The biggest budget risk in a thrift store is the “it’s only $3” effect. Go in with a short list, such as winter boots for a growing child or one serving platter, and set a spending cap before you walk through the door. Many stores rotate their stock constantly, so it is better to visit often with a short list than to wait for a rare perfect find.

Finally, remember the other half of the equation: donating what you no longer use keeps goods circulating and may give you a tax deduction if you itemize, so keep a receipt and ask a tax professional how your records should look.


Leah Carter Avatar

You might also like